Insurance - Property & Casualty Dividend Stocks

Browse 27 dividend-paying stocks in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry. Compare yields, payout ratios, and growth rates.

Last updated: June 26, 2026

This page lists 27 dividend stocks in the Insurance - Property & Casualty industry, with an average dividend yield of 2.88%. RLI Corp. (RLI) currently has the highest yield in the group at 8.84%. Over the past five years, W.R. Berkley Corporation (WRB) has grown its dividend the fastest, at 42.64% per year. The average payout ratio is 30.56%, which generally leaves room for future dividend increases. Insurance - Property & Casualty sits within the Financial Services sector. Use the table below to compare every Insurance - Property & Casualty dividend stock by yield, payout ratio, and five-year dividend growth.

Overview

Dividend Stocks

Average Yield

2.88%

Highest Yield

8.84%

RLI

Best 5Y CAGR

+42.64%

WRB

Average Payout

30.56%

/

27 stocks

		52 Weeks		Frequency
ADM.LFinancial Services Admiral Group plc	£34.60	26.24 36.86	6.16%	Semi-Annual	73.05%	+9.86%
AFGFinancial Services American Financial Group Inc.	$135.89	122 150	3.92%	Quarterly	31.91%	+13.59%
AIZFinancial Services Assurant Inc.	$260.77	183 269	1.31%	Quarterly	17.22%	+5.16%
ALLFinancial Services Allstate Corporation	$231.60	188 237	1.87%	Quarterly	9.03%	+13.12%
CBFinancial Services Chubb Limited	$330.82	264 346	1.19%	Quarterly	13.72%	-9.46%
CINFFinancial Services Cincinnati Financial Corporation	$177.73	143 181	2.10%	Quarterly	20.30%	+7.71%
GJF.OLFinancial Services Gjensidige Forsikring ASA	NOK 268.40	241 303	5.61%	Annual	76.75%	-3.98%
HCIFinancial Services HCI Group, Inc.	$173.17	136 211	0.96%	Quarterly	7.01%	0.00%
HMNFinancial Services Horace Mann Educators Corp.	$50.67	40 52	2.90%	Quarterly	35.43%	+3.13%
HSX.LFinancial Services Hiscox Ltd	£18.61	12.17 18.90	2.10%	Semi-Annual	25.29%	—
KMPRFinancial Services Kemper Corporation	$25.40	23 65	5.11%	Quarterly	177.78%	+1.30%
KNSLFinancial Services Kinsale Capital Group Inc.	$308.43	287 513	0.28%	Quarterly	3.35%	+13.56%
LFinancial Services Loews Corporation	$110.90	89 115	0.23%	Quarterly	3.18%	+0.12%
MCYFinancial Services Mercury General Corporation	$104.12	64 108	1.23%	Quarterly	8.37%	-12.80%
ORIFinancial Services Old Republic International Corp.	$40.01	36 47	8.75%	Quarterly	29.19%	+30.34%
PGRFinancial Services Progressive Corporation	$215.54	189 268	6.70%	Quarterly	70.70%	+13.49%
PLMRFinancial Services Palomar Holdings Inc.	$117.84	101 161	0.00%	N/A	—	—
PRAFinancial Services ProAssurance Corporation	$25.00	23 25	0.81%	Quarterly	0.00%	-48.86%
RLIFinancial Services RLI Corp.	$55.13	47 73	8.84%	Quarterly	14.92%	+40.82%
SAFTFinancial Services Safety Insurance Group Inc.	$72.49	67 81	5.21%	Quarterly	86.52%	+0.22%
SIGIFinancial Services Selective Insurance Group Inc.	$94.51	72 96	1.81%	Quarterly	22.16%	+10.80%
STCFinancial Services Stewart Information Services Corporation	$64.56	56 79	3.17%	Quarterly	46.21%	+11.30%
THGFinancial Services Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.	$207.56	161 213	1.86%	Quarterly	18.67%	+6.61%
TRUPFinancial Services Trupanion Inc.	$23.97	21 58	0.00%	N/A	0.00%	—
TRVFinancial Services Travelers Companies, Inc.	$318.29	249 326	1.46%	Quarterly	13.13%	+5.24%
UFCSFinancial Services United Fire Group, Inc.	$50.15	26 52	1.49%	Quarterly	13.71%	-10.90%
WRBFinancial Services W.R. Berkley Corporation	$69.29	63 79	2.77%	Quarterly	7.63%	+42.64%